House Speaker Brendan Sharkey’s plan to subject nonprofit hospitals and colleges to property taxes would have far reaching implications for the city of Hartford.
Whether the results would be good or bad is hard to tell.
We cringe at the thought of new taxes, but Hartford’s significant stockpile of tax-exempt property is a key reason the city’s mill rate is highest in the state. That has put a heavy tax burden on businesses, making executives and developers skittish about investing capital here.
The idea of new revenue coming in to offset a portion of the city’s high business tax burden is attractive, but we’re skeptical that’s how any new funds would actually be used.
Sharkey unveiled his reverse PILOT (payment in lieu of taxes) program plan during Hartford Business Journal’s March 14 Municipal Collaboration Event at Goodwin College. He was serving up red meat to a crowd full of cash-strapped first selectmen and mayors, who face the very real challenges of balancing local budgets amid a slow economic recovery and rising costs.
The Hamden Democrat’s plan, which likely won’t get serious consideration until 2015, would require nonprofit hospitals and colleges to pay property taxes and then seek state grants to offset a portion of the cost. That means hospitals and colleges would not bear their full property tax burden, but it would cost them more than they pay today, which is nothing.
The property tax is municipalities’ primary revenue source, which puts big cities at a major competitive disadvantage.
Nearly 51 percent of Hartford’s property, for example, is tax-exempt because it’s owned by state, educational, nonprofit, or religious groups. The state reimburses the city to offset some of that lost revenue, but it doesn’t cover the full freight.
In 2012, the city valued tax-exempt property at about $3.6 billion. Yes, that’s billion with a “B.”
In Hartford, a reverse PILOT would likely target three institutions: Hartford Hospital, St. Francis Hospital and Medical Center, and Trinity College.
They each have a major economic impact employing thousands of people and drawing customers to local businesses, but they also own lots of tax-exempt real estate that drains millions of dollars from the city’s coffers.
The risk of taxing these institutions is that we saddle them with higher costs at a time when they’re already experiencing financial pressures that aren’t going away anytime soon. That could, in turn, lead to higher student tuition and hospital bills, which would defeat larger efforts to make college education and health care more affordable.
At the same time, nonprofits use city resources without contributing tax dollars.
Clearly, there are no easy answers.
Sharkey is right to draw attention to Connecticut’s tax policies because they need to be reformed. The state’s property tax is considered the least business friendly.
Beyond his reverse PILOT program, Sharkey has also pitched capping property taxes and shifting more municipal expenses onto the state’s back.
These are grand ideas in the Land of Steady Habits, and it could be the type of outside-the-box thinking this state needs to become more economically competitive.
But we urge Sharkey and the state legislature to tread carefully. Lawmakers should spend this short legislative session commissioning the necessary studies that calculate the bottom line impact of Sharkey’s and any other major tax reform initiatives. The public typically scoffs at state government studies, but attempts to dramatically change Connecticut tax policy should entail plenty of research.
And when, or if, these ideas are turned into actual legislative proposals, the business community should have a primary seat at the debate table.
