A funny thing happened at the State Capitol last week. A bunch of Democratic lawmakers engaged in election year demagoguery inadvertently found a right answer. (Pardon the double entendre.)
Amid national polling showing that roughly two-thirds of the population is worried about rising gasoline prices, Democratic leaders last month grabbed an idea Republicans have been pushing since last summer. It’s time, they solemnly proclaimed, to cap the state’s hidden 7.53 percent tax on fuel. There’s no reason the state should collect even more taxes as the price rises. The tax should only be collected on the first $3, a move that could save motorists an estimated 7 to 10 cents a gallon in this era of $4-plus gasoline.
While their rhetoric was sound, their heart wasn’t really in it. They had no intention of holding the line on taxes. That’s just not who they are. So their plan included a sunset clause, ending the tax relief just in time for — you can’t make this stuff up — the largest ever jump in the state’s fuel tax. Current law has the fuel tax going up from 7.53 to 8.81 percent on July 1, 2013.
That’s when the funny thing happened. They looked around and saw they’d painted themselves into a political corner. The tax-relief gesture was so well received by voters that having it sunset, then slapping on a tax increase, would hand their opponents quite a club.
So the Democrats sucked it up and passed a permanent cap on the fuel tax. It didn’t adjust the rate or stop the 2013 rate increase; it just limited the levy to the first $3 per gallon.
In the grand scheme of things, this is small change. The plan costs the state about $5 million. But cash is cash to an administration already trying to scrounge pennies to close a looming, albeit hard to measure, budget deficit.
We’re sympathetic to concerns about rising gasoline prices. Each penny increase at the pump sucks billions from the economy. Any relief is a help. And we dislike indexing taxes in a way that can produce windfalls for the government at the expense of the taxpayers. So this adventure results in a win for everybody not on the Malloy budget team.
It’s just a shame we got there by applying electoral calculus rather than reason.
Connecting the dots
There’s an art to parsing the nuances of your opponents’ language. And officials at the state’s two large teacher unions and its hundreds of school districts would do well to pay careful attention to Governor Malloy’s words as he expressed frustration with a compromise education bill that passed a key committee without any meaningful reform to teacher evaluation or tenure.
While indicating he’d veto such a bill, he also opined that “There is no reason to spend any more money under the current formula. Period.”
That could be big news, considering his budget proposal includes an extra $50 million for school districts. That money could come in really handy as the cement starts to harden on the size of the state’s budget deficits for this year and next.
Recall this is the same governor who fired a bunch of state troopers after they had the gall to reject his concession deal. That one got overturned in the courts but the case for additional school funding seems largely discretionary. And a scorned Malloy is building a record as a man who believes in swift and certain retaliation.
There’s still plenty of time for education reform forces to mount a counter-attack. Virtually all the players have expressed their displeasure with the compromise bill.
But absent a compromise, things may get much worse between the governor and the education community before they get better.
