NU concessions cost investors, customers $439 million

The shareholders and ratepayers of Hartford-based Northeast Utilities will pay more than $439 million over the next several years to secure Connecticut and Massachusetts regulatory approval for the proposed merger with NStar.

NU shareholders are on the hook for at least $139 million that can’t be passed onto customers while Connecticut ratepayers will shell out $300 million to improve the state’s energy infrastructure and Massachusetts ratepayers will suffer the costs of buying power from more expensive sources of generation.

Despite the high cost of winning state regulatory approval, the companies and their analysts still see the merger as a long-term positive, producing $784 million in net savings over 10 years and creating a dominant company through the marriage of NStar’s strong cash flow with NU’s long slate of improvement projects.

“Our hope is the commissions in both Connecticut and Massachusetts will approve the settlement,” said Jeff Kotkin, NU vice president for investor relations.

ADVERTISEMENT

The $4.7 billion merger was first proposed on Oct. 16, 2010 and would cast a new Northeast Utilities as New England’s largest utility with 3.5 million customers spread over six electric and natural gas subsidiaries in Connecticut, Massachusetts and New Hampshire. NStar and NU have obtained all the necessary approvals except from the Connecticut Public Utilities Regulatory Authority and the Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities.

In order to secure PURA and DPU approval, NU and NStar agreed to a number of concessions with the governors and attorneys general of each state, along with the Connecticut consumer counsel and the Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources. The concessions don’t necessarily mean PURA and DPU will sign off on the deals, but the agreements remove virtually all objections to regulatory approval.

The most significant concession for shareholders is the forgoing of $40 million in recoverable storm costs. NU electric subsidiary Connecticut Light & Power incurred $263 million in costs from the power restoration efforts following storms in August and October, all of which would have been recoverable through rates.

Now, not only must the company’s shareholders forgo $40 million, but the company agreed to not try to recover the remaining $223 million through rates until Dec. 1, 2014. Because CL&P already paid the bills from its storm expenses, carrying that extra costs over the next three years will create $6 million in annual interest payments.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We have incremental debt that we would not have otherwise,” Kotkin said.

Those costs come on top of the $30 million NU shareholders already put out to refund CL&P customers who lost power for more than a week after the October storm.

“The storms are costing shareholders a lot of money,” said Maurice May, utility analyst from Power Insights-Wellington Shields of New York City.

NU also agreed to provide electric rebates of $25 million to Connecticut customers and $21 million to Massachusetts customers plus freezing current distribution rates until 2016 in Massachusetts and Dec. 1, 2014 in Connecticut.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We said the merger would create significant savings,” Kotkin said. “This is a way for the savings to be presented right upfront.”

But the rate concessions will impact the new company’s cash flow, particularly in the first year after the merger. Because of this limited cash flow, Fitch Ratings — one of three rating firms for utility debt — said it would likely downgrade the bond rating of the NStar electric subsidiary after the merger is complete.

“Over the time of the rate freeze, you would see some margin compression, and that would impact cash flow,” said Glen Grabelsky, managing director at Fitch Ratings.

If downgraded, NStar electric would go from having the highest rating among all U.S. utilities to having the second highest rating. However, the cost of borrowing will increase whenever the subsidiary incurs debt for major projects.

The rating for CL&P is anticipated to rise after the merger because NStar’s balance sheet makes NU a more attractive company financially, Grabelsky said. However, Fitch hasn’t had a chance to factor in how the latest Connecticut concessions will impact their ratings.

“That is one of the issues we will be looking at with Connecticut Light & Power,” Grabelsky said. “The financial impact of the concessions may not be as significant on CL&P’s rating.”

NU shareholders also must put out $15 million to help Connecticut build its energy economy through electric vehicle infrastructure, microgrids and energy efficiency projects. Lastly, NU is opening $20 million worth of land for public use and preservation.

“They gave away a little bit more in Connecticut,” May said.

For ratepayers of NU’s subsidiaries, the biggest impact will be on CL&P customers, who must shoulder $300 million in required upgrades to the electric utilities system to boost resiliency against outages in the future.

The concession agreement calls on NU to design a plan to gradually phase in those costs to consumers, limiting to $25 million in recoverable costs in the first year. Eventually, all those costs will be recovered through ratepayer bills.

“It will be part of the rate base,” Kotkin said.

The greatest unknown cost of the concessions to ratepayers is the requirement that the company buy 27 percent of the power produced by offshore renewable energy project Cape Wind. Those costs will be passed onto Massachusetts ratepayers.

The details of that power purchase agreement still are in the early planning stages, but the expected costs of electricity from Cape Wind will be higher than the average costs of grid energy.

“The costs of power from Cape Wind is very expensive, but that will be blended into all the other generation sources,” Grabelsky said.

Just like the Cape Wind costs, the other Massachusetts concessions will be borne only by Massachusetts ratepayers, such as commitment to solar power, electric vehicle infrastructure, energy efficiency programs and avoiding employee layoffs.

With the concession deals in place, Connecticut PURA is expected to approve the merger April 2 followed by Massachusetts DPU approval April 4.

The savings generated by the merger and the capabilities of a company with significant cash flow and a long project list make the regulatory expenses worthwhile, May said.

“They had to do what needed to be done, and they did it,” May said. “It is small compared to the benefits of the merger.”

Learn more about: