Medical society challenging Aetna-Humana merger approval

Citing a lack of transparency and public involvement, the Connecticut State Medical Society has filed Freedom of Information requests for documents related to the state Department of Insurance’s approval of the proposed Aetna-Humana merger.

In a statement, the medical society said the insurance department’s review process “raises serious questions about the veracity of the review, and the reliability and quality of the determination.”

The insurance department announced on May 26 it had approved the merger back in January.

The medical society said these steps in the review process were flawed:

ADVERTISEMENT

The insurance department’s determination to complete its review “without objection” was made on Jan. 22 of this year, but the public was not notified until May 26.

The Form A (change of control application) filing was not required, so the insurance department chose not to hold any public hearing – despite the gravity of the decision on the proposed merger.

The Form E filing (determination of competitive impact) was not made available for public review on the insurance department website at any time.

“It is difficult to understand how [the insurance department] could have made a determination of this magnitude without any public engagement, or even any public awareness of the fact that the review process was underway,” said Matthew Katz, the society’s CEO and executive vice president.

ADVERTISEMENT

An insurance department spokesperson said on Jan. 22, the department made the determination that the proposed acquisition would not substantially lessen competition or create a monopoly in Connecticut as Humana has a small market footprint in this state. As part of the department’s analysis process, an economist was hired to provide an independent evaluation.

Because the state of Connecticut does not have a domestic Humana Insurer, a Form A change of control application, was not required to be filed and therefore a public hearing was not required, the spokesperson added.

After learning of the insurance department’s determination, the medical society, working with the Connecticut Campaign for Consumer Choice, immediately filed a Freedom of Information Act request. The request asked for “any & all information” used by the department in making its determination.

The Connecticut State Medical Society wants the insurance department to re-examine its process and reconsider approval of the Aetna-Humana merger. Katz said it also wants the department to publicly commit to an open, fair and transparent process in reviewing the Anthem-Cigna merger, allowing all interested and concerned parties to voice concerns, ask questions, and participate in the decision process.