Already a Subscriber? Log in
Get Instant Access to This Article
Subscribe to Hartford Business Journal and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
- Critical Hartford and Connecticut business news updated daily.
- Immediate access to all subscriber-only content on our website.
- Bi-weekly print or digital editions of our award-winning publication.
- Special bonus issues like the Hartford Book of Lists.
- Exclusive ticket prize draws for our in-person events.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article
Duncaster has won the first of two zoning approvals it needs to expand its Bloomfield senior living campus onto land that neighbors say was supposed to remain open space.
The Town Plan and Zoning Commission voted 6-1 on Oct. 22 to amend the nonprofit’s master plan. Commissioner Kevin Gough cast the lone dissenting vote.
The change allows Duncaster to seek 91 new residential units on the eastern portion of its property at 20-80 and 90 Loeffler Road. The plan calls for a 61-unit independent living apartment building and 30 cottages.
The amendment also raises the campus’s residential density limit to 279 units and allows taller buildings. But the vote does not authorize construction. Duncaster still needs the commission to approve a special permit and site plan, which cover the project’s design and site details.
At town staff’s request, the commission continued its hearing on those applications to Nov. 19, leaving questions about tree removal, sidewalks and engineering details unresolved.
Duncaster, a Life Plan community that has operated on Loeffler Road since the early 1980s, would build the apartments and cottages on vacant land at the corner of Loeffler Road and Mountain Avenue. The proposal also includes an addition to existing campus buildings and 42 new parking spaces.
The commission approved an earlier version of the project 4-3 in June 2024. Eight neighbors appealed, and in October 2025 a Superior Court judge overturned the approval, finding that technical failures had kept remote participants from following much of the public hearing.
Duncaster withdrew that application in June and filed a revised proposal.
The new plan is slightly smaller and set farther back from Loeffler Road. It drops two cottages, for a total of 30, bringing the total to 91 new units, down from 93. The cottages and their driveways would sit about 40 feet farther from the road than before, leaving more than 100 feet between the road and the nearest cottage.
A berm, a 6-foot fence and new plantings would add screening. The town’s wetlands commission approved those changes in August.
Duncaster also scaled back the density limit it requested. The approved cap of 279 units is down from the 386 Duncaster sought in its earlier application.
The master plan amendment allows buildings up to 48 feet tall for the campus addition and 47.5 feet for the apartment building, exceeding the zone’s standard 35-foot limit. Duncaster architect Dustin Julius of RLPS Architects said the additional height would accommodate pitched roofs that conceal mechanical equipment.
Attorney Kenneth Slater of Halloran & Sage, who represents the eight neighbors, argued that the town’s original approval of Duncaster in 1982 came with an understanding that the land along Loeffler Road would remain undisturbed.
The town allowed dense senior housing on residentially zoned land in exchange for preserving that open space, Slater said.
“That was the quid pro quo of the zoning that was put in place in the early 1980s,” he said.
Building and Land Use Director Jonathan Colman said town staff searched extensively but found no binding action by the town or commission requiring the land to remain open space.
The town’s 2012 plan of conservation and development is also inconsistent on the property’s future, Colman said. Its future land use map calls for moderate-density housing, while its agricultural resources map identifies the land as farmland.
Duncaster attorney Joseph Williams of Shipman & Goodwin argued that statements made in the 1980s reflected the original developer’s intentions rather than a legally enforceable restriction.
“There was no promise,” Williams said.
Most commissioners sided with Duncaster on the master plan amendment. Chair Byron Lester pointed to his support for three expansions at Seabury, Bloomfield’s other Life Plan community, as evidence of the need for more senior housing.
“To ask Duncaster, who’s in the same business as Seabury, why they would want to grow is obvious,” Lester said. “There’s a need.”
Gough, who opposed the amendment, said the proposal represented a major departure from the land use and density established in the original master plan.
Several issues remain before the commission can act on the special permit and site plan.
Colman said staff has “significant questions” about how many trees Duncaster plans to cut down. Staff also has outstanding engineering comments and questions about walking paths and crosswalks.
Duncaster also plans to pay a fee rather than build affordable units under the town’s inclusionary zoning rules. Williams said rent or sale-price restrictions are incompatible with the Life Plan model, in which residents pay an entry fee and a monthly service fee. The amount of the payment will be determined after the final plans are approved.
Duncaster has 188 independent living apartments, 42 assisted living apartments and 60 skilled nursing beds, President and CEO Kelly Papa said. The nonprofit employs more than 300 people.
