Consumer spending hints slow recovery

Q&A talks about consumer spending and the overall economy with Richard Tavolieri, a partner in the Hartford office of Deloitte & Touche LLP.

Q: The Deloitte Consumer Spending Index that tracks consumer cash flow as an indicator of future consumer spending slipped lower in February. Why is that?

A: Real home prices are the primary drag on the index and have been for several months. These prices drive the ability to refinance and, during the housing boom, were a good leading indicator of activity that added strongly to consumer’s cash flow. The tax burden and real wages were also in negative territory and while initial unemployment claims improved slightly, it was not enough to offset the other negative components.

 

ADVERTISEMENT

Q: What are some of the further repercussions of the decline in home prices? Your findings show that nationwide they are down 12 percent in the last year. What are the impacts going to be on business and not just consumers?

A: Declining home prices impact the balance sheets of consumers and banks that hold inventories of unsold homes. For banks, this means that larger write-offs have to be taken, hurting their profitability. For consumers, contracting home prices increase the number of homeowners underwater on their mortgages, increasing the likelihood that they will default. It also has a negative wealth effect — consumers who feel poorer spend less. It also reduces opportunities to refinance, reducing household cash flow and spending.

 

Q: Deloitte economists point to the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis’ revised real incomes from July through December as being up by roughly 1 percent, yet real income growth is down to 0.5 percent in January and has steadily decelerated since peaking at 3.8 percent in October 2010. Since October 2010, roughly 18 months, have real incomes declined overall or have they grown? What does the growth or decline mean?

ADVERTISEMENT

A: Real incomes as of January 2012 were up 0.5 percent from a year ago. They have grown, just barely. Rising energy prices and a change in employment toward more temporary employment has depressed real, inflation-adjusted wage growth. Income growth is the main driver of consumer spending which makes up 70 percent of gross domestic product. Without income growth, consumers have had to reduce savings and increase their debt levels in order to maintain spending levels. Rising debt and falling savings are not sustainable over time and without a renewal in income growth, consumer spending will stall, negatively impacting overall economic growth.

 

Q: Where does the tax burden fall in all of this discussion? Isn’t there a perception that lower incomes mean lower taxes?

A: A declining tax burden suggests weakening income growth. When the economy is flush, incomes grow and households get pushed into a higher tax bracket. A rise in the overall average rate of taxation is a reflection of a rising tide lifting all boats. It is a reflection of rising consumer incomes, which, in turn, will give a boost to consumer spending.

ADVERTISEMENT

 

Q: There’s an interesting statistic in the Deloitte economic analysis. Every penny increase in gasoline costs consumers an extra $3.8 million each day. With gas prices up nearly 50 cents a gallon since mid-December, the increases translate into $5.7 billion a month and $68.4 billion a year. With negligible income growth, what segment gets most affected by the rise in gasoline prices? Where are consumers cutting back?

A: Should prices rise into the summer months and cut into household budgets, consumers may pare back discretionary spending categories, such as consumer electronics, and focus on necessities.

Consumers may also change habits, such as consolidating shopping trips when gas prices are high. Consumers have become more price-sensitive in general and trade down on quality in order to get a better price.

 

Q: Despite limited growth in consumer spending and purchasing power, many retailers continued to improve performance, according to Deloitte findings. How is that possible? Are consumers less risk averse after being down for so long? Are they tired of not spending?

A: Looking at the Commerce Department’s monthly retail sales data and the same store sales data that retailers have released, many retailers appear to be improving performance. Retailers have been efficient and targeted with their inventory, promotions and multi-channel strategies, which may be contributing to the improvements they’ve experienced.

Additionally, despite low confidence levels and factors that strain household finances (like gas prices, housing issues, unemployment, etc.), consumer spending does not appear to be falling. Consumers appear to be going into more debt and credit card use seems to be steadily increasing.

 

Q: The report also mentions falling jobless claims? Does that mean more employment or just loss of eligibility?

A: The decrease noted in the index relates to initial unemployment claims. It’s a reflection of layoffs, which is now at a relatively low level.

Consumer spending hints slow recovery

Learn more about: